Hah Clay, very interesting !
I actually was planning on something similar but I lack any
temperature measuring tools apart from a flue meter ;)
Here's a picture of two transistors removed from an Amplifone board.
The grease is completely crumbled and dried out. So is the mica. The
result is a very poor transition between transistor and heat-sink.
web.jpg
I recently repaired and re-worked an Amplifone deflection board for a
guy in the UK and (as always) I replaced the crumbled and dried grease
and mica's on the power transistors.
I had run the board for quite some time before just to see if I would
notice any heat difference just using my bare hands.
After I replaced the mica's and grease I was able to keep touching the
cooling body WAY longer than before. This already proved what I
thought about this, and what you've proved in a much more scientific
way :D
20 degr. Celsius is an immense difference and about what I would
expected from my earlier experience. And still, the transistor
obviously survived ! ;)
However if you start working on a board, this is something to do with
all cooled transistors and power regulators like 78xx's and 79xx's.
I've got a question though: How much grease do you use ?
I've always tried to get a very even but thin film but when I once put
up a picture Mark Spaeth said it was way too much grease.
Here's some pics of two transistors I put on separate heat-sinks
because the WG6100 was removed from it's frame half-way and I wanted
to get rid of the triangle-shaped side:
Grease applied:
web.jpg
Mica on top and pressed half-way with my thumb so there's an even film:
web.jpg
And the finished result:
web.jpg
Of course I removed the excess grease in the holes etc. And of course
I put another layer on the bottom of the transistor about the same way.
What do you guys think, too thick ? I can't imagine how to get an even
thinner layer. Pics would be great !
And as mentioned, even with this method, the cooling is insanely
better than before.
I only use the regular grease because it's WAAAAAYYY cheaper than the
over-priced "fancy" stuff for case-modders.
The mentioned differences are merely about 1 degree Celsius. Maybe the
ultimate for over-clockers of CPU's, but for this application it's non-
sense.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
** Unsubscribe, subscribe, or view the archives at http://www.vectorlist.org
** Please direct other questions, comments, or problems to chris@westnet.com
Received on Mon Sep 14 10:42:32 2009
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.8 : Mon Sep 14 2009 - 14:50:00 EDT